A 19th-Century Chart That Still Gets It Right
A farmer from Ohio named Samuel Benner lost almost everything during the Panic of 1873, one of the first major financial crises in U.S. history. Instead of giving up, he decided to study economic cycles and patterns in commodity prices and industrial activity. The result was a book published in 1875, titled Benner’s Prophecies, featuring a fascinating chart that indicated the best times to buy and sell stocks — and it turned out to be remarkably accurate.
Now, 150 years later, Benner’s chart continues to impress traders and historians alike with its predictive power.
The Benner Cycle: When to Buy, When to Sell
Benner divided the market into two main cycles:
- Major Cycles (thicker golden-brown line)
- Minor Cycles (thinner gray line)
And within these, he established three categories:
- A – Panic Years: market collapses.
- B – Prosperity Years: good times, but ideal for taking profits and selling.
- C – Hard Times: periods of pessimism and low prices, perfect to buy cheap stocks.
The logic is timeless: buy when others are fearful, and sell when everyone is euphoric.
The Predictions That Came True
Benner’s analysis borders on prophetic. In 2019, his chart indicated a “prosperity year” to realize profits — and what happened next? The 2020 pandemic crash.
In 2007, it signaled time to sell — just before the 2008 financial crisis.
In 1999, it predicted another downturn — exactly when the dot-com bubble burst.
In 1945, it warned of a market top right after World War II ended.
In 1931, it marked a perfect buying opportunity — and the market rallied soon after.
Even when not perfectly timed (as in 1927, two years before the Great Depression), the direction of each move was impressively accurate.
2026: The Year to Sell
According to Benner’s current cycle, 2026 falls under category B — a year to sell.
Not necessarily a panic year, but one signaling the start of a major correction.
And today’s environment fits the script: we are witnessing the rise of the Artificial Intelligence bubble.
Companies like Nvidia have reached unimaginable valuations — over $5 trillion — while the S&P 500 keeps breaking record highs.
The signs of euphoria are everywhere. And as Benner’s cycle teaches, euphoria always precedes a fall.
Bitcoin and the U.S. Market Are Aligned
In the video, the analysis extends to Bitcoin and U.S. stock indexes, showing the same cyclical behavior.
- Bitcoin has printed five consecutive bullish monthly candles — a classic overbought signal.
- The S&P 500 continues to climb with almost no corrections.
- The monthly RSI shows extreme levels of optimism.
Even though the trend is still upward, a correction seems both healthy and likely, potentially reaching 20% to 30% on the S&P 500 — enough to trigger a bear market.
Parallels With Modern Predictions
Interestingly, modern investors like Michael Burry — the man who predicted the 2008 crash — are buying put options on tech giants like Nvidia and Palantir.
History doesn’t repeat itself exactly, but it rhymes remarkably well.
When the Past Speaks Louder Than the Present
Samuel Benner’s 150-year-old chart continues to resonate with modern markets.
He may not have been a prophet, but he understood something timeless:
“Market psychology never changes — only the assets do.”
If 2026 truly turns out to be a year for selling, as Benner’s cycle suggests, we could be on the brink of another major global correction.
A Warning — and an Opportunity
This content is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice.
But if you’d like a team of specialists to manage your investments — buying and selling automatically — check out Nomos Assessoria, an official XP Investimentos partner.
They manage Brazilian stocks and even trade mini-index futures, so you can focus on global markets and crypto while experts handle your portfolio.
-> Check out the video:
>> See also: